icon-cookie
The website uses cookies to optimize your user experience. Using this website grants us the permission to collect certain information essential to the provision of our services to you, but you may change the cookie settings within your browser any time you wish. Learn more
I agree
blank_error__heading
blank_error__body
Text direction?

Evaluating Valuation

Evaluating Valuation

Connoisseurship, Technology, and Art Attribution in an American Court of Law

Chapter:
(p.89) 5 Evaluating Valuation
Source:
Moments of Valuation
Author(s):

John Brewer

Publisher:
Oxford University Press
DOI:10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198702504.003.0005

The case of Hahn versus Duveen, tried in New York in 1929, hinged on the attribution of a painting supposedly by Leonardo Da Vinci. Was attribution, as the art dealer Duveen claimed, primarily a question of experts’ intuitive judgment, or should it be established, as Hahn’s lawyers asserted, by empirically verifiable scientific methods? In adjudicating the conflict between these two very different regimes of truth, both the court and the jury rejected intuitive judgment and therefore the testimony of some of the most important experts in the Old Master art market. The evaluators were evaluated and found wanting. The outcome was site specific—it pointed to the weakness of intuitive art expertise as legal evidence—but in the long run it helped shape a closer co-operation between those with the experienced eye and experts in the scientific properties of pictures.

Keywords:   expertise, connoisseurship, art expertise, art market, intuition, art world, Old Masters, art science, Joseph Duveen

Measure
Measure
Related Notes
Get a free MyMarkup account to save this article and view it later on any device.
Create account

End User License Agreement

Summary | 5 Annotations
Was attribution
2019/10/13 20:52
should it be established
2019/10/13 20:53
by empirically verifiable scientific methods?
2019/10/13 20:53
a question of experts’ intuitive judgment
2019/10/13 20:53
in the long run it helped shape a closer co-operation between those with the experienced eye and experts in the scientific properties of pictures
2019/10/13 20:54